1.   An appeals court disagreed, and the Supreme Court upheld that decision Friday.

2.   An appeals court disagreed, however, and said punitive damages are taxable.

3.   A federal appeals court disagreed, however, and said the new law should apply even though the allegedly fraudulent acts occurred before its enactment.

4.   A federal appeals court disagreed, however, and said the suit could proceed.

5.   A New York federal appeals court disagreed, however.

6.   A New York-based federal appeals court disagreed.

7.   A Louisiana state appeals court disagreed.

8.   A San Francisco-based federal appeals court disagreed, however.

9.   But a federal court disagreed, saying he had defaulted on the loan and the government properly foreclosed on the property.

10.   But the appeals court disagreed, saying the disproportionately small number of black students at the college did not itself constitute discrimination.