1.   Cookies looked as if they had been cut to shape with a ruler and an Exacto knife.

2.   Generally, small, delicate cookies look best with small, delicate ornamentation.

3.   One panelist commented that this cookie looked the most homemade but lacked flavor.

4.   The cookies look like macaroons and, of course, contain crushed potato chips.

5.   The hoopla boils down to a lot of butter, a little technique and some very different ideas about how a cookie should look and taste.

6.   This cookie does not look nearly as rich as it is.