1.   A manufacturer does have some obligations which arise independently of his position as buyer or seller.

2.   But Shell argues that although it has an obligation to the communities, so has the government, which is largely absent.

3.   Citizens have an obligation to obey law by virtue of the fact that it is made in accordance with established procedures.

4.   Citizens have an obligation to obey the law.

5.   Employers have an obligation to treat all employees equally.

6.   First, do states in fact have moral obligations?

7.   Having promised to cut taxes, the government now has an obligation to do so.

8.   In their view serving the state was the highest moral duty and no state had external obligations.

9.   It has, in fact, been argued that he has greater obligation to obey because of his participation.