1.   New evidence has emerged to contradict earlier claims.

2.   The article flatly contradicts their claims.

3.   The newly disclosed documents contradict White House claims that Mrs Clinton did not play a significant role in the firings.

4.   The result was disappointing because it so patently contradicted his claim to be a truly national leader.

5.   This rather contradicts his claim never to have been an IRA member.

6.   Although Gnazzo at the time insisted his family retained an interest in only one of the shops, but records contradicted that claim.

7.   A curator for the Metropolitan Museum of Art, Susan Vogel, later found evidence contradicting the claim.

8.   But independent audits contradicted those claims, he said.

9.   But the few records he located contradicted that claim.

10.   But that claim is contradicted by Lindsey Rodriguez, a seventh-grader who watched in disbelief as her friend was shot to death.