1.   Another federal appeals court upheld that ruling, and Raytech unsuccessfully appealed to the Supreme Court.

2.   Blixt said that if the jurisdiction ruling is upheld, the companies also plan to contest FDA assertions about tobacco that were included in the regulations.

3.   A constitutional court is considering whether to uphold the ruling.

4.   A Cincinnati-based federal appeals court upheld the ruling.

5.   A Georgia federal trial judge agreed with Warren, and a three-judge appeals court panel initially upheld that ruling.

6.   A deeply divided Arizona Supreme Court upheld that ruling, but reversed the conviction on other grounds.

7.   A federal appeals court upheld the ruling.

8.   A federal judge has upheld the ruling and set a deadline for installing the new commissioners.

9.   A federal trial judge dismissed the case, and the appeals court today upheld that ruling.

10.   A New Orleans-based appeals court upheld that ruling and Vander Zee appealed unsuccessfully to the Supreme Court.