1.   But a lawyer involved in the case said on Wednesday night that Starr had claimed in the oral arguments that Mrs. Clinton was not protected by such a privilege.

2.   But a lawyer involved in the case said tonight that Starr had claimed in the oral arguments that Mrs. Clinton is not protected by such a privilege.

3.   Chief Judge Norma Holloway Johnson ruled last month that no such privilege exists, but the Justice Department filed its intent to appeal Monday.

4.   If Congress now believes such a privilege is warranted, it, unlike this court, is free to create one.

5.   Supreme Court decisions have said that such a privilege exists, but that it can be overcome for legal purposes in certain situations.

6.   The judges said it was up to Congress to decide whether to grant such a privilege.

7.   The judges also said it is up to Congress to decide whether Secret Service employees should be granted such a privilege.

8.   Giving Irbid such a privilege, as some critics pointed out, must have been concluded to servea certain objective.

9.   No other country has such a privilege.

10.   Such a privilege gave Franco a virtual veto over the appointment of Spanish bishops.