1.   She has relied on resources like faded navigational charts and has canoed to islands that have no means of public access.

2.   The other parties claim that the captain was negligent for ordering the final, right turn without checking navigational charts that showed the location of the reef.

3.   Problems found on unsafe ships included defective fire safety equipment, inadequate navigational charts, corrosion, unusable lifeboats and poor ventilation in engine rooms.

4.   The reef appears on navigational charts and is marked by a lighted beacon and a radar reflector on a buoy, said harbor master Sunny Hoo.