1.   After the appellate judges began deliberating in October, Napster made agreements with former business foes like Bertelsmann, the parent company of the BMG music unit.

2.   After the appellate judges began deliberating in October, Napster made agreements with former business foes like Bertelsmann AG, the parent company of the BMG music unit.

3.   Since the judges began deliberating in October, Napster has made friends with former business foes like Bertelsmann AG, the parent company of the BMG music unit.

4.   Since the appellate judges began deliberating in October, Napster has made agreements with former business foes like Bertelsmann AG, the parent company of the BMG music unit.