1.   The article was based on information provided to us by Dr Williams.

2.   But the articles were based on more than voice-mail messages.

3.   But this article is based on information obtained independently.

4.   However, officials at Koch Industries said they suspect other negative articles were based on the information.

5.   Karl Malone did not say that and the New York Timees article was not based on anything, so I direct the witness not to answer.

6.   Moreover, the article is based on a contradiction.

7.   The article was based on a report, prepared by Charles G. LaBella, a former Justice Department investigator, that had been kept secret for two years.

8.   The article was based on documents that are under court seal.

9.   The article was based on interviews with her specialist, Dr. Kathy Miller, that began last August.

10.   The articles were based on the findings of a private investigator, Humberto Lopez Mejia.