11.   A three-judge panel has ruled that the university was right and that the jury was wrong.

12.   A trade organization panel ruled earlier that the original American tax benefit violated global trade rules against export subsidies.

13.   A three-judge panel ruled that regulations issued under the Clean Air Act discriminated against foreign oil refiners.

14.   A three-judge appellate panel ruled last year that the ban was unconstitutional.

15.   A three-judge panel has ruled that oral arguments in his challenge to the law will not be heard until December.

16.   A World Trade Organization dispute panel has ruled that a United States tax subsidy for businesses violated international trade rules.

17.   After conducting hearings in Illinois, the panel ruled in favor of petitioners.

18.   After the hearing ended Tuesday afternoon, Garth declined to say when the panel would rule on the lawsuit.

19.   But an appellate panel ruled last week that the cutting could begin again.

20.   But at least one arbitration panel has recently ruled otherwise.